Et... ta mère aussi !

Beau film ouvert et sincère sur l'amitié, le sexe et la vie. Une érotique inhabituellement authentique, belle et parfois sérieusement étouffante, des performances d'acteurs choquantes et brillantes, surtout de deux jeunes gars, et une représentation magistrale de la psychologie en général. L'épilogue triste m'a semblé un peu contradictoire - d'un côté, il a donné une dimension plus profonde à ce qui s'était passé (et m'a vraiment touché), mais d'un autre côté, il n'était pas nécessaire pour l'incroyable impression laissée par le film, et en réalité, il a seulement perturbé sa positive ambiance et l'envie de vivre. (31/10/2004)

Whoever didn’t dream about something similar when they were seventeen must have been living their lives wrong. Only in this country you need to replace the sea with a fishpond. The result could still be… similar. (01/12/2015)

This film is quite conflicting from my point of view. I had heard and read positive reviews about it before, so I was determined and had to check it out. And what I got was not at all what I expected. I was quite disappointed with the two lead actors – Gael García Bernal and Diego Luna – they seemed quite obnoxious and their acting seemed quite far-fetched at times. But Maribel Verdú was at her best - her performance immediately got my attention. The whole story is built up quite steadily and the script is colourful and spicy. And the occasional spoken interventions in the plot added originality to the film. Well, it won't be my favourite film, but in terms of quality, it's above average in many aspects. (13/05/2010)